Will Your Anchor Hold?

There's an old hymn, written by Priscilla Owens back in 1882, that asks a simple question: Will your anchor hold in the storms of life?

I've spent a good many years in ministry now, and I've come to believe that question isn't really about whether the storms will come. They will. It's about what holds you when they do. For a long stretch of my life, I had that question completely backwards. I thought the question was whether I was strong enough to keep everyone else anchored. It never occurred to me to ask whether I was anchored myself.

For 26 years, I served the church as a congregational minister. I loved the work. The baptisms, weddings, funerals, the Sunday mornings, the conversations, the privilege of standing with people in those thin places between life and death. Even the meetings. OH THE MEETINGS! But somewhere along the way, the person I was began quietly losing ground to the minister everyone seemed to need me to be….the strong one, the steady one, the one who copes, the one everyone could count on. Underneath that uniform was a person who wasn't coping nearly as well as everyone thought. My body was keeping its own accounts, tallying every hard thing I carried quietly and patiently.

Sooner or later, it presented the bill.

I was exhausted, angry, struggling with boundaries, drinking too much, and experiencing some very dark thoughts. And still, I told myself I couldn't stop. People needed me. There was another sermon to prepare, another crisis to attend to, another person who needed caring for. I was ticking nearly every box on what we called the compassion fatigue checklist, and I didn't even recognize it.

I tell that story in the first episode of Will Your Anchor Hold?, a six-part series I've put together for the Ministry Forum podcast. Not because my story is particularly remarkable, but because, tragically, it's so very common. And because I suspect there are others who need to hear that they're not alone.

What if we've been asking the wrong questions?

For years, the language I knew for what happened to me was compassion fatigue. It seemed to make sense. We begin with a full tank of compassion, and every person we care for draws a little more out until eventually there's nothing left. But compassion isn't necessarily the thing that's draining us. One of the most significant things I've learned along the way is that there's a difference between empathy and compassion. Understanding that difference has changed how I understand my own experience, and what it might mean to care for others without losing ourselves in the process. I explore this question in this series. along with some other deeply ingrained beliefs about what it means to serve others faithfully:

  • Give till it hurts.

  • I'll rest when I'm dead.

  • It would be selfish to stop.

  • If I don't do it, who will?

We take something beautiful and true, that love is sacrificial, and bend it until exhaustion becomes the measure of our faithfulness. We wear our lack of Sabbath like a merit badge. We forget that loving our neighbour as ourselves includes the person doing the loving. And perhaps most dangerously, we convince ourselves that burning out is simply the price of admission for a life spent caring for others. I believed a good many of those things myself. But measured sacrifice can be holy. Self-destruction was never the ask.

We need to name what we're carrying

One of the things I've learned is that we have a habit of reaching for one word to describe almost everything that goes wrong in this work.

Burnout.

We're exhausted? Burnout. Dreading Monday morning? Burnout. Snapping at the people we love? Must be burnout. And because we use one word, we tend to reach for one cure. Take a vacation. Practice some self-care. Book a massage. Get more rest.

Now, rest is beautiful. Rest is holy. Rest is good. But I remember taking four, sometimes five weeks of vacation, and finding myself overwhelmed again almost as soon as I returned. The time away hadn't failed because I'd done it wrong. It was simply the wrong medicine for what was actually wrong.

As I've come to understand, the strain we experience in ministry isn't always one thing. There are different wounds and pressures, different ways that the work of caring can affect us, and if we're going to tend to those wounds, we need to be willing to name them. We also need to recognize the conditions in which we're doing this work. Fewer volunteers, increasingly complex pastoral needs, administrative demands that multiply even as our capacity shrinks. The shifting place of the institutional church in Canadian society, and the quiet fear that somehow its decline is happening on our watch. Layer those things together with our own personal circumstances, our grief, our anxieties, and everything else we carry, and it's little wonder that so many ministry leaders are struggling.

But where do we begin? That's much of what I wanted to explore through these six episodes. How we can begin to recognize what is happening, understand it, and respond with something more helpful than another instruction to just take better care of ourselves.

Doing the work, kindly

Those of us who care for others are often remarkably good at recognizing when something isn't right in another person's life. But we're not always nearly so good at recognizing those same signs in ourselves - I know I wasn't. Part of this journey is learning to turn that same compassionate attention toward ourselves. To recognize when we're carrying more than we should, and perhaps even question whether some of those burdens were ever ours to carry in the first place.

And to do that with what Dr. Gabor Maté calls compassionate curiosity. Not the interrogation we're so good at: What's wrong with me? Why can't I handle this? What kind of leader falls apart like this? But a gentler question: What happened to me? What am I carrying?

If we can't look at ourselves with at least the same compassion we'd offer the person sitting across from us, this work will not go well. There are tools and practices that can help us do that. Some are surprisingly simple. Others require more difficult conversations, or a willingness to change things we've long accepted as part of ministry.

But there's a danger even in that… because those of us who are wired to do, to accomplish and produce can turn our own well-being into yet another task to complete, and that brings me to perhaps the most important thing I've learned…

Stop doing. Just be.

We ministry leaders tend to be doers - give us a problem, and we'll build a plan! Give us a free afternoon, and we'll find three things to fill it with. And the church doesn't always help. For all our lovely theology of grace, we're remarkably good at rewarding doing. We celebrate the busy minister, the full calendar, the leader who's always available. We measure our congregations by their activity and our leaders by their output.

But Sabbath was never intended to be a reward for getting everything done.

Sabbath is the thing that reminds us our worth was never about doing enough in the first place.

It's not simply a break from our real lives so we can get back to the work. The stopping is the point. When we stop, when we cease producing and accomplishing and justifying our place in the world, we have an opportunity to rediscover something that all our busyness can make us forget: We are loved. We are enough. Not because of what we do, but simply because we are.

You matter enormously, and it does not all depend upon you.

So, will your anchor hold?

I’m sharing some things about my own journey that weren't particularly easy to say out loud, but I’m sharing them because I know how lonely this work can become. How easily we can convince ourselves that everyone else is managing just fine, that we're the only ones struggling, that somehow we ought to be stronger. But you are not alone in ministry.

Not in the strain, not in the exhaustion, not in the difficult work of naming what's happening, and not in the slow journey toward something healthier.

My hope for this six-part series is that you'll find something here that helps you recognize what you're carrying, question some of the assumptions you've made about caring for others, and begin tending to your own well-being with a little more compassion. Not so you can do more, but so you can last.

So, will your anchor hold?

That's a question worth spending some time with.

And I hope you'll join me as we explore it together.

Previous
Previous

Waiting & Watching Together: NEW Advent Reader for 2026

Next
Next

New Retreat Resource: Made in Canada