WYAH 4: Doing the Work

Understanding the problem is one thing. Learning to respond to it is another.

In this episode, John begins to explore the practical work of paying attention to ourselves with honesty and compassion. He reflects on the importance of self-awareness, noticing our own warning signs, and resisting the urge to treat every difficult season the same way.

Along the way, he introduces simple practices and helpful tools that can support ministry leaders in caring for themselves with the same grace they so readily offer to others. It's an invitation to move from reacting to responding, one honest step at a time.

Doing the Work
Rev. John Borthwick

About Rev. John Borthwick

John Borthwick leads Ministry Forum as the Director of the Centre for Lifelong Learning at Knox College. John knows intimately the ups and downs of congregational ministry. Having served in congregational ministry for 25 years, John has lived it and, as he would say at times, just survived and often thrived in this unique and challenging role. He is passionate about supporting ministry leaders as they answer the call to serve. During COVID-19, John responded to the needs he witnessed among his colleagues and friends by creating The Abbey, a virtual space for community and learning. He intends to translate his recent experience on a much larger scale as he stewards Ministry Forum. John looks forward to being available to ministry leaders - reach out to him today!

Show Notes

Follow us on Social:

Transcript

[Introduction]

Welcome to the Ministry Forum podcast, where we believe that you are not alone in your ministry journey. I'm the Reverend John Borthwick, your host, coming to you from the Center for Lifelong Learning at Knox College. Here we connect, encourage, and resource ministry leaders all across Canada, in the joys, the struggles, and everything in between. I love that I get to do this work, and most of all, that I get to share it with each and every one of you. So, thanks for giving us a listen today. Whether you're a seasoned leader or just starting out, this podcast is made with you in mind.

 

[John Borthwick]

Welcome back to "Will Your Anchor Hold?” I'm Reverend John Borthwick. There's that moment in the first Indiana Jones film, “Raiders of the Lost Ark”, when Indy looks down into an ancient chamber and looks at the floor, and realizes it's absolutely writhing with snakes, and he groans that famous line, "Why did it have to be snakes?” I love his face in that scene, the dread, the reluctance, the whole "this is not ideal" of it, and yet he's the one who goes down first. That, right there, is a picture of leadership, being willing to step into those uncomfortable spaces before anyone else does. Now, most of us in ministry won't find ourselves in an actual pit of snakes. At least I hope not. But I suspect that you know the feeling of looking at a situation and thinking, "I really wish this weren't mine to step in.” For three episodes now, we've been building towards something. I've told you my story. We've named the lies. We built a vocabulary, and today, well, today we do the bravest thing of all. We climb down into our own pit and take an honest look at what actually is going on down there. This episode is called "Doing the Work" because that's exactly what it is. Now, before we climb down, let's have a word about how we go, because there's a wrong way to look honestly at yourself, and most of us in this line of work are experts at it. It's the interrogation. We are gifted at this. What is wrong with me? Why can't I handle this? What kind of leader falls apart like this? And truthfully, that's not honesty. That's just the strong one lie, holding a clipboard, that you're meant to be the strong one, and you better do better. And that's not the approach we want to take. The posture that we actually need is something quite different. And Dr. Gabor Mate, and if you don't know his body of work, I'd highly recommend that you get acquainted with it. He calls it “compassionate curiosity.” Compassionate curiosity. It trades what's wrong with me for a gentler, truer question: What happened to me? What am I carrying? Do you remember back in the first episode the one health professional who finally asked me the right question? My chiropractor, “John, are you under a lot of stress?” that's the whole posture right there: being curious, being kind, not accusing, and here's something I want you to listen to carefully. If you can't look at yourself with at least the same compassion you'd offer to the person sitting across from you, this work will not go well. That's called self-compassion, and it's so needed in the work that we are called to do as helpers. So kindly, we go down kindly. Now, what's actually down there? Last time, I said the strain in this work is almost never one thing. It's a stack, and doing the work means naming your particular stack. So let me show you what I mean with something I've been chewing on lately. I've been in a lot of conversations with ministry leaders who describe themselves simply as “busy”. But the longer we talk, the clearer it becomes that busy is kind of covering for something a good deal heavier than just being busy.

So I've tried to map it out a little bit, and it's almost like an equation for overwhelm is how I'm framing it, and it goes something like this: you start with a low, humming, existential dread, a sense that the very ground is shifting under our feet, and you add to it the feeling of living right next door to a cultural dumpster fire. A news cycle that never once pauses, a public discourse that only ever seems to heat up. And then you layer on a steady little drumbeat about the institutional church that we're all just watching something sink in slow motion. I've jokingly called it “Titanicing”, because you know exactly how the story ends, and yet here you are, still on the ship. And for a lot of leaders, that narrative turns personal fast. If attendance dips, if the energy wanes, it can all start to feel a bit like a verdict, like it happened on your watch. Now, the people who actually study this shift, like the Reverend Dr. Stuart Macdonald in his book “Tradition and Tension” will tell you plainly: it is not your fault. The ground moved for reasons far bigger than you but knowing that and feeling it are two very different things. And there's usually someone in our lives happy to make sure that we keep right on feeling it. And then on top of all of that, the plainest thing of all-the actual workload of ministry today: volunteers have aged out, fewer people carry more, pastoral needs grow more complex, the admin multiplies, and somehow the expectations never seem to shrink, just because the capacity of the team did. And here's the thing: any one of those, on its own, you could probably manage but line them all up; the existential anxiety, the cultural tension, the institutional story, the blame that you quietly swallowed, and the ballooning workload - and the results. is fairly predictable. It becomes a pit that nobody wants to climb down into. So here is your first real piece of work. What's your equation look like? Which of those are you actually carrying? And just as importantly, which ones aren't even yours to carry, because the point is not that every leader is drowning. The point is that most of us are carrying far more than we let on. Once you can see your stack, the next question is a kinder one than we usually ask ourselves: How would you even know when it's getting to you? Well, here's the good news: your body, your behavior, and your emotions-they're all trying to tell you all the time. They're kind of faithful that way. The trouble is that most of us in this work have grown far more fluent in everyone else's signs and signals than in our own. We'll catch the tremor in a parishioner's voice from clear across the sanctuary, and completely miss that if we're honest, we haven't slept properly in a month. So, here’s an exercise worth doing, and again, it's worth doing incredibly gently. Sit for a moment with your own kind of warning signs, and you'll notice that they tend to gather in three places: the physical, the jaw that you're clenching, the sleep that seems to have gone sideways, the gut that's just acting up for some reason, the shingles. Then behavioral, the second and third glass, the doom scrolling, the withdrawing, the canceling on people who feed you and support you. And then thirdly, the emotional; the irritability, the quick temper, the dread of certain phone calls, and maybe even that numbness. There's even one specific one worth watching for. It's called the "must be niced" phenomenon. When you find yourself losing your feelings of generosity towards other people, and you start feeling judgmental or resentful about all of their activities, or maybe it's their time off. You're scrolling on social media, and you see a friend or a colleague posting about their vacation, and you immediately get that little, ugh, that must be nice. And here's the thing, it's not really about them at all. It's more about your own feelings of depletion, your own longing for that very same thing, whether that's rest, or leisure time, or balance. That's not who you are.

That's a warning light going off. So, pay attention to the signs that show up first for you. They're telling your story, a story of how you're really doing, and it's up to us to be curious about that. And this matters because it can help you figure out where you are along that kind of continuum of your well-being, it's a simple picture really, it's quite basic. You know, you're either in the green, or the yellow, or the red, and it's a continuum. You might find yourself at different places and spaces in any given day, week, month, year, time of life. The green is healthy. You're coping. You're yourself. The red is that wall of crisis and collapse. The place I was heading in the very first episode. And yellow. A little bit of yellow in our lives is not so bad. It's the whole ball game, because yellow is where your warning signs are flashing, and you haven't crashed yet. Yellow is where you can still do something about it. The entire reason to know your own warning signs is so that you can catch yourself in yellow, and act instead of discovering you are in trouble only after you've slammed into red. Most of us blow straight through yellow. You need to be careful when that happens. We blow through it because we've trained ourselves for years just not to notice when that yellow light comes on. Doing the work means learning again to feel, to sense, to recognize when the yellow has come into our lives. And we can invite others into this journey, caring partners, close friends, trusted colleagues into this whole exploration, and as you feel safe to ask those people in your life what changes they notice about you that tell them you're in the yellow, because they care about you, and they will be delighted to tell you, truly. Sometimes the people around us can read our dashboard far better than we can. Now, if all of this self-assessment is starting to feel like just one more thing on an already groaning to-do list, take heart. You don't have to reinvent the wheel all by yourself. Wiser people have already built proper, validated tools for exactly this, to check on you. It's called the “ProQOL”, and it's one of the best that's out there right now. Called ProQOL, the Professional Quality of Life Measure. I took this one and I blew the doors off it. I had no idea that I was struggling the way I was until I took this little test, and it said, "You might have some things that you need to work on.” Now, it just takes a few minutes, and it gives you a read on three things. It will talk about your burnout, your secondary traumatic stress, and I really love that they measure this one, your compassion satisfaction. Because it isn't all about failing a test or getting a bad mark. It isn't all about deficits and warning lights. Compassion satisfaction is the deep fulfillment that comes from doing this work and doing it well, the part that actually fills you back up. Any honest self-assessment has to count the good, too. You can find that assessment freely available at “proqual.org”. The link will be in the show notes. And if you'd like to go deeper on many of these other tools I've been describing today, a few simple searches online will be fruitful. But if you're looking for a one-stop shop for everything, I'm happy to recommend one. Now, full disclosure: I noted in my story that occasionally I teach with an organization called Tend Academy, and I want to be crystal clear that I'm not paid a single nickel to say any of this, but they host what is hands down the Canadian resource hub for a wealth of material on this subject: secondary traumatic stress, empathic strain, all of it. Their toolkit is exactly where I'd send you. They've got plenty of free resources there, and if you wanted fuller access, you can get it with a paid annual subscription. I'll drop a link in the show notes as well, if you're interested.

So that, in a nutshell, in a very small amount of time, is kind of the work that we need to do, going down first into our own pits, but kindly doing it, naming our equations, learning your warning signs, feeling the yellow Before the red. It's not glamorous, and it's not a one-time event. You've heard me say it before; it's a practice. But hear me say, self-awareness is not the finish line; it's the doorway. Knowing precisely what you're carrying, and exactly where you're standing, is worth very little, if you don't know what to do next. And that, what you actually do, how you refill, how you keep going for the long haul, is where we're headed from here, because you're not alone in this, and you do not have to do it alone. Next time we're going to be talking of out of your abundance, and it begins with something almost embarrassingly simple: the pause. Until then, will your anchor hold? Let's make sure that it will.

 

[John Borthwick]

Thanks for joining us on the Ministry Forum podcast. We hope today's episode encouraged you and reminded you that you are not alone in ministry. If this episode resonated, tell someone. Please don't give us a secret. And if you can, subscribe, rate, or leave a review wherever you listen. It helps us reach more ministry leaders just like you, and honestly, it reminds us that we're not alone either. Find more resources and ways to connect at ministryforum.ca and follow us on social media at Ministry Forum. Until next time, may God's strength and courage be yours. May you be fearless, not reckless. May you be well in body, mind, and spirit, and may you be at peace.

Next
Next

WYAH 3: Naming It: Beyond Burnout