WYAH 3: Naming It: Beyond Burnout

Naming what's happening doesn't solve it overnight. It does, however, make it possible to begin responding with greater wisdom and care. Sometimes healing starts simply by calling something by its proper name. This episode slows things down long enough to name the different kinds of strain ministry leaders carry. John introduces language for burnout, empathic strain, secondary trauma, moral distress, grief, and the many other realities that often get lumped together under a single label.

Naming It: Beyond Burnout
Rev. John Borthwick

About Rev. John Borthwick

John Borthwick leads Ministry Forum as the Director of the Centre for Lifelong Learning at Knox College. John knows intimately the ups and downs of congregational ministry. Having served in congregational ministry for 25 years, John has lived it and, as he would say at times, just survived and often thrived in this unique and challenging role. He is passionate about supporting ministry leaders as they answer the call to serve. During COVID-19, John responded to the needs he witnessed among his colleagues and friends by creating The Abbey, a virtual space for community and learning. He intends to translate his recent experience on a much larger scale as he stewards Ministry Forum. John looks forward to being available to ministry leaders - reach out to him today!

Show Notes

Follow us on Social:

Transcript

[Introduction]

Welcome to the Ministry Forum podcast, where we believe that you are not alone in your ministry journey. I'm the Reverend John Borthwick, your host, coming to you from the Center for Lifelong Learning at Knox College. Here we connect, encourage, and resource ministry leaders all across Canada, in the joys, the struggles, and everything in between. I love that I get to do this work, and most of all, that I get to share it with each and every one of you. So, thanks for giving us a listen today. Whether you're a seasoned leader or just starting out, this podcast is made with you in mind.

 

[John Borthwick]

Welcome back to “Will Your Anchor Hold”. I'm the Reverend John Borthwick. Last time we went hunting for the lies that we tell ourselves and the mindsets sitting underneath them, and I left you with a promise that today we'd build out a vocabulary. Because here's something I've come to believe all the way down: you cannot tend a wound that you refuse to name. There's a moment in Mark's Gospel that I often come back to. Jesus meets a man in absolute torment, and the very first thing he does isn't to lecture him, or fix him, or even to tidy him up. He asks him a question: “What's your name?” And the answer comes back, “My name is legion, for we are many.” Naming the thing was the beginning of the healing and notice it wasn't one thing. It was legion. It was many. Hold on to that because that's the whole episode today. We have one word that we reach for very nearly everything that ails us in this work and in ministry, and the word, say it with me, “burnout”. Feeling flat, burnout, dreading Monday morning, burnout, snapping at the people that you love most must be burnout. It's become our legion, one tidy name that we slap across a dozen very different injuries, and because we've got the one name, we reach for the one cure, usually some version of rest. Take your vacation. Practice a little self-care. Maybe run a bath. Light a candle. Book a massage. Eat more kale. Now hear me carefully and clearly, rest is beautiful. Rest is holy. Rest is good. We said so in the last episode. But if you've ever come back from two glorious weeks of vacation, feeling wonderful for maybe 90 minutes or so, and then felt the dread come rolling straight back in the minute you opened your inbox, the minute you walked through the door. Then you already know the secret. That was me when I was in the midst of my struggles, and I took four, sometimes five weeks in a row, and by about 11 a.m. on the first day back, I was in my car heading back home to recover. The time disconnecting from it all didn't fail because I did it wrong or - doesn't fail because you do it wrong. It failed because it was the wrong medicine for what was actually wrong. Because burnout, it turns out, is not just one thing, and the right cure depends entirely on which thing you're actually facing. And we clergy, oh my goodness, we are strange this way. We are magnificent at pointing out and naming things for other people. We'll gently help someone name their grief, their doubt, their sin, their need for grace, and then we'll go home. And we'll call our own six different wounds by one lazy, lazy word, and wonder why nothing seems to help. So, let's name them properly, like the legion they are. First one is burnout, the real thing, named precisely. Burnout is the injury of your working conditions. That's what happens when the machinery grinds you down. The workload, the endless meetings, the underfunding, the difficult board, the gnawing sense that no matter how much you pour in, it's never quite enough, and nobody quite notices or seems to care. And here's the surprising part: burnout, properly understood, isn't really about the people that you serve at all. You can adore your congregation and still be hollowed right out by everything around them, and that matters enormously, because if it's your working conditions breaking you, then no amount of personal resilience is going to fix it. The cure isn't a better attitude; it's changed conditions, boundaries, a renegotiation. workload, honest conversations with leadership, and sometimes yes, maybe even a different workplace entirely.

I do wonder if that's what Todd Ferguson was getting at in his book "Stuck: Why Clergy Are Alienated from Their Calling, Congregation, and Career…and What to Do about It”. This is one we've talked about before around Ministry Forum, because it isn't the calling to care for people that's pulling clergy under; it's the tidal wave of running the church that keeps wiping us out. The second term is “empathic strain”, the one we spent all of last episode on. It's that injury of feeling with over and over and over again, and the slow wearing down of empathy itself. Different wound, different medicine. This is the one that answers to the practice we talked about, moving from empathy toward compassion, finding your sweet spot, and learning your way back to it. The third is secondary trauma, sometimes called “vicarious trauma”. This is the injury of indirect exposure. You weren't there, and it's different from empathic strain, though I find it's an area we dismiss far too easily in ministry as just part of the job. It didn't happen to you, but you heard it. You got to hear all the graphic details in your office or at the bedside, the disclosure whispered to you at the end of a service, the case file that you were handed to read and to prepare for, the confession you cannot now unhear, and that kind of stuff, it just hitches a ride home with you, and it will not get out of the car. Over time, that exposure leaves a mark, intrusive images, a quietly shifted sense of how safe the world really is. There's even a name for one of its sneakier symptoms: “the silencing response”. It's what happens when we get so saturated that, without ever once deciding to, we actually start shutting people down, changing the subject, rushing them along, subtly signaling, "Please, not one more terrible thing today”. We just go quiet, and at its most severe, we end up not being able to feel anything. I mentioned this before: not feeling happy or sad. We feel numb, just nothing at all. If you've ever caught yourself doing that to someone who needed you just to listen, that isn't a character flaw. It's a wound, and it has a name, and its cure isn't necessarily a silent retreat, although that can be rejuvenating, hear me say that. It's managing exposure and having somewhere safe to set the stories that you come alongside down. The fourth is one I think is criminally undernamed in ministry, and it's called “moral distress”. This is the injury of the system. It's what happens when you're required, maybe by a rule, a policy, a polity. An institution to do something you believe in your bones is wrong, or just as often when the red tape stops you from doing the thing that you know is right. In ministry, this can show up in a very personal way, running hard into the limits of our own capacity, maybe? The ache of simply not being able to care for everyone who needs us, that can get us. But just as often, it comes from outside us, our ministry context, context, even our denominational structure, can create or quietly maintain real constraints on our freedom to serve, to care, and to respond creatively to the needs right in front of us. I think of the family you couldn't help the way that you longed to because there was simply no budget line for it. And lately, I'll admit, I've found myself wondering whether our present denominational and judicatory structures are actually deepening the moral distress that ministry leaders carry, whether our polity, for all its gifts, is actually keeping us from being nimble and creative in the face of the very real human resource crises our Presbyteries are facing. You see, moral distress isn't exhaustion. It's a wound that impacts your very soul, your integrity, maybe, and you cannot self-care your way out of it. A spa day does precisely nothing for a violated conscience. What it asks of us is different and harder. Naming it out loud, finding your voice advocating for change, and once in a while, standing your ground at real cost.

Now, there are two more worth quickly naming, just so the picture is complete. “Direct exposure” when the trauma actually does happen to you or right in front of you. The threat, the accident, the tragedy you witnessed the day violence came to your own door-that is profoundly impactful. And “work-related grief and loss”. Maybe it's a colleague who leaves, a mentor who retires, the ministry that quietly closes, the funding that simply vanishes. We so rarely give ourselves permission to grieve these significant changes in the life and work of ministry. We need to. We need to mark them. We need to grieve them. We need to acknowledge them. Now, when you step back and look at all of that together, you might notice something. Every one of those injuries came from a different place, and that's the second gift I want to hand you today. Not just names for the wounds, but a map of where they come from. The people who study this closely have laid out seven territories, seven sources of work-related strain, and again, let me name them lightly now, and we'll come back and actually walk through them next time. So, the first one: your personal circumstances, your own story, your health, the fact that you might be raising young kids and caring for aging parents at the very same time. The second is what we just mentioned: work-related grief and loss. Third, direct exposure. Fourth, indirect exposure, secondary traumatic stress. Fifth, system changes and challenges, the red tape, that moral distress that it breeds. The sixth is our working conditions. That's the burnout country. And seven, your sociocultural context, the way your own identity meets the political and cultural climate around you. A quick peek at the news, at social media, or even just outside your own front door today, should be enough to show you the profound impact that this reality can have on how you turn up to your work and how you face daily living. And here's the punchline: it almost never is just one of these; it's kind of like a stack. When I look back now at my own collision, the one I told you about in the very first episode in this series, it was never a single tidy little thing. It was indirect exposure. All those tragedies that I had quietly absorbed. It was working conditions. It was my own personal circumstances humming away underneath, amplifying every single bit of it. It was legion, and the reason nothing worked for so long is that I kept reaching for one cure. Just push through. Just pray harder. Just take a break to treat a whole stack of different wounds. Naming your stack is the thing that finally lets you reach for the right medicine. And if you need to re-listen to this part of the episode just to capture some of this. I would really encourage you to do so. So, this is the work that naming does. It isn't just navel gazing, and it isn't self-indulgent. In the scriptures, it's the very first task that God hands human beings. This gift of being able to name things. It's an act of stewardship, perhaps. It's right there at the beginning of all things, and you cannot steward a wound that you won't name. You cannot tend what you insist on calling by the wrong word. But naming it out here in the abstract, in general, that's only the rehearsal. The real work is turning this map on yourself. Where exactly is your strain coming from? What are your particular warning signs-the ones your body and your behavior start flashing long before you hit the wall, but that's for next time. That's where we stop talking about all this in generalities and start doing the work on you. Until then, will your anchor hold? Let's make sure that it will.

  

[John Borthwick]

Thanks for joining us on the Ministry Forum podcast. We hope today's episode encouraged you and reminded you that you are not alone in ministry. If this episode resonated, tell someone. Please don't keep us a secret. And if you can, subscribe, rate, or leave a review wherever you listen. It helps us reach more ministry leaders just like you. And honestly, it reminds us that we're not alone either. Find more resources and ways to connect at ministryforum.ca and follow us on social media at Ministry Forum. Until next time, may God's strength and courage be yours. May you be fearless, not reckless. May you be well in body, mind, and spirit, and may you be at peace.

Previous
Previous

WYAH 4: Doing the Work

Next
Next

WYAH 2: The Lies We Tell Ourselves